A larger model number does not mean that every interior dimension is larger. Pelican’s 1170 and 1200 demonstrate why a protective-case shortlist should start with the equipment layout, rather than a photograph of the closed case.
Research-based comparison: These are manufacturer dimensions checked October 13, 2026. Gunfire has not performed fit, drop, water or durability tests on either case. The diagram is conceptual and is not drawn to either model’s scale.
Compare the usable envelope
| Specification | 1170 Protector | 1200 Protector |
|---|---|---|
| Interior, L × W × D | 10.54 × 6.04 × 3.16 in | 9.31 × 7.13 × 4.12 in |
| Exterior, L × W × D | 11.64 × 8.34 × 3.78 in | 10.67 × 9.75 × 4.86 in |
| Weight with foam | 2.10 lb | 2.75 lb |
| Weight without foam | 1.96 lb | 2.55 lb |
The 1170 is longer inside; the 1200 is wider and deeper. That is a dimensional comparison, not a claim that either will hold your complete kit.
Make a measured packing plan
List each accessory or electronic device that will share the case. Measure it in the configuration you intend to pack, including attached parts that affect the envelope. Draw a simple top view and side view before choosing a case. Include the protective material and space needed to remove each item.
Use the published dimensions as an initial screening tool. A rectangular outline does not establish clearance at corners, against lid foam or around an irregular object. If the fit is close, obtain the manufacturer’s detailed information or confirm the layout with a seller offering an appropriate return arrangement.
Separate the shell from the configuration
Both official listings offer foam and no-foam options, and publish separate weights. Check which configuration a quotation includes. Foam, dividers and other organizing materials occupy part of the interior; they are not additional usable capacity.
For a carried kit, add the contents and packing materials to the shell weight. For shelf or vehicle storage, compare the outside footprint with the available space. A case can suit the contents yet fit poorly in the place where it will normally be kept.
Check the claim you need
Pelican describes both products as protective cases with sealing features. This guide does not independently validate those manufacturer claims. A weather-protection description does not establish a burglary rating, fire-resistance rating or compliance with a separate travel requirement.
Both pages link to the manufacturer’s Guarantee of Excellence. Read its current terms for the exact item, intended use and region rather than assuming a product-page headline covers every loss or damage scenario. Current comparable retail pricing was not established here; request quotes for the same configuration.
A useful shortlist
Start with the 1170’s longer interior when length is the limiting measurement. Start with the 1200’s wider, deeper envelope when those dimensions constrain the layout. Then verify the complete packing arrangement. This gives each case a clear role in the comparison without inventing a hands-on verdict.
See the 1170 product feature and Pelican company profile.
Sources & further reading
Sources reviewed 2026-10-13.
Prepared for Gunfire Magazine with AI assistance from the linked source material and the publication’s editorial brief. This piece does not claim original interviews, on-site reporting or hands-on product testing.